First of all Im glad your eye is ok. Second being a former contact lens wearer I know the perils of not getting anything in your eye! The products took forever to arrive (more than a mounth!) Im sorry, Im not familiar with that ingredient! IDK if products with that ingredient are made with less of a fine powder, or if there are chunkier ones available too. It minimizes the risk of wiping glitter in to your eyes and it goes in to the trash, and not down the drain! There are alternatives to using plastic glitter, like synthetic fluorophlogopite (which is lab-made mica) and borosilicates, which are two ways Lush replaced plastic glitter in their products, that have widespread usage in cosmetics already. I always read the ingredients in everything before I purchase, and the 1st time I ever saw fluorphlogopite as an ingredient was when Hourglass came out with their Ambient Lighting products. Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please Its interesting to see how widespread it is, and that even older shades from Urban Decay may contain it. The eyeliner has a cartridge of .55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. At worst? As a person who has problems with my eyes, I steer very, very clear of any glitter whatsoever. If you suspect that youve scratched your eye, even if youve been able to flush out the foreign body or bodies, seeing an eye doctor to determine the best course of action from there is a good idea. However, in looking at your list above and running the ingredients through my database, I see that PET is in quite a few highlighters (I know, not used on eyes, but still, interesting as I wonder if these products can scratch the face) and in one eyebrow product, Fenty MVP pencil. Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. However, you cannot combine the discount codes with other offers on their website when placing your order. The purple liquid liner is perfection. For more information, please see our Its cold as heck here right now! Lash Primer & Serums. I actually tried to confirm with Lit that their glitters were eye safe, and they referred me back to my own warning notice posted on their glitters, so in a very roundabout way, they actually wouldnt confirm they were safe. Briefly, with respect to the second concern: cosmetic grade glitter generally means plastic glitter or polyethylene terephthalate (PET). I'm worried because nobody informs me anything, not even the carrier. Thanks for the in-depth look into this. A wag once said, The more I learn, the confuseder I get. How true. Makeup palettes are gorgeous as expected, very pigmented and pretty good quality!! This is true for any and all reactions to cosmetics. I guess Ive been living under a rock because Im 43 and just discovered them. hydrating, plumping lip gloss with the ultimate glassy finish , Swipe on to hydrate lips with a crystal clear sheen! Eye Primer & Base. Urban Decays Heavy Metal Glitter Gels and Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliners were released last year and are listed for eye use. At best, you risk mild eye irritation. My personal takeaway from my recent experience and after sifting through what little information was available is to use caution when working with products near or around the eyes, particularly when working with larger particles, whether more traditional sparkle or glitter, and when working with mascara wands (Ive poked myself in the eye at least a dozen times over the years) and brushes (keep em clean!). The purple liquid liner is perfection. I also realize that a lot of things can cause damage to the eye, even if technically safe, whether thats makeup or you know dust or sand! thanks a lot no one is talking openly about it. Support us by Sharing It! The Best Under-$50 Beauty Finds on Amazon, How Eighth Day's Intensive Moisturizer Soothed My Dehydrated, Post-Treatment Skin, The FDA Just Approved a New Patch Treatment for Excessive Sweating. Ill need to weed out shadows with glitter or microglitter fallout and just keep the ones that are formulated to stay on well. Theres no universal definition for those finishes one brands glitter finish might use mica or borosilicates and another brands will use plastic glitter. Because of my age (advanced) and problems Ive had with my eyes (retinal tears), this whole business of these non-eye-safe glitters is an important one to me but even younger people with healthy eyes well, a lot of them are concerned about this ongoing inclusion of these plastic based glitters in eye products. I try to ignore the pressed glitters in my Colourpop palettes but it would be better if they werent in there at all. Build your own palette, create a color combination, or discover look ideas to try. MAC would also be a safe bet solely because of the overall solid quality and variety of products. Thank you for understanding! Once the enforcement discretion period is over, FDA will resume our enforcement of these non-permitted colors.. What can I do? Everyone should have a good grasp of the general dos and donts of what to do if something gets in your eye, and if youre someone who regularly wears eye makeup, particularly anything with larger particles (like glitter), Id say its well-worth knowing what to do (or not do) before you need to know it! Palettes were amazing, packaging was great, and the deal was amazing! Fixed that, thank you! Keep in mind, however, that the CIR is not a regulatory body and was originally established by the industry trade association (currently known as the Personal Care Products Council); they have a set of procedures that they say keeps their review process independent from the Council and the cosmetics industry. They're my favourite lip . Thank you so much for this thorough and fantastically researched overview! Outstanding piece, Christine. As previously mentioned, there are two ingredients that are commonly used in cosmetics, including eye products, that might work in lieu of plastic glitter: borosilicate glasses and synthetic fluorphlogopite. MAC Glitters used to have a similar warning, but presently, for many of their glitters, their warning is now Approved for adhesion on the eye area using Duo Adhesive.. Other than a few random blog posts and a Yahoo Answers thread from 2009, there aren't any solid answers. I definitely have to remember to use mine daily! Thanks for making sure your readers are informed about the products they purchase (or in some cases, ones we dont purchase.) The one that does come up is by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR), which publishes findings and safety assessments of ingredients used in cosmetics, and they published their final report in 2013 on PET glitters used in cosmetics. I think pressed glitter should be sold at least separately, if brand wants to include that in their range. I like that they let me know about my order; I really appreciate the use of DHL. Needless to say, Im not wearing them anymore, and might try to get another named brand company that isnt some off brand youtuber approved /money maker too type deal. ColourPop Over the Liner Lippie Pencil ($5.00 for 0.04 oz.) Thank you for all your hard work. In terms of colors, a nude lip liner in a neutral hue close to the natural shade of your lips is good to have on hand, while a lip liner in brown gives you that nostalgic '90s look. Lip Tints & Balms. Moreover, the product has dimethicone, which prevents shine by absorbing excess sweat on your skin to keep the bronzer looking pristine. Reviewers complaining about ColourPop most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and phone number problems. Find your next foundation or concealer match! Im sure it was a scary moment. Im thoroughly impressed/amazed with your supernatural tenacity. When you make a purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. When jt arrived it was missing the actual Mandalorian pallet. ColourPop has been in operation since 2014, and it has been manufacturing makeup using methods that dont involve cruelty to animals. Shipping 60. Ive bought the hypoallergenic nars palettes before and my eyes stars watering and burning. Combination skin. Light, Neutral undertones. Your eyes never look irritated in your photos, and Ive often wondered how you use and remove so much makeup every day with seemingly no eye or skin irritation. Regarding the Borosilicate, I find it in three PM Decadence shades (likely the very three that I hate using because they feel gritty: Enigma, Sinful and Gold Standard); two ABH Sultry shades (Rose Quartz and Cinder) and one ColourPop Brown Sugar shade (Saute). You also asked if the regulatory status of Red 28 Lake (CI 45410), Red 7 Lake (CI 15850), and Yellow 6 Lake (CI 15985) has changed in that they are now allowed for eye-area use. Also, the large particle size means they are more sparkly. Thanks, Christina! When doing this ColourPop review, we checked customers experiences with the brand and the products they offer. The report looked at the potential for ocular injury and found that: Use studies of eye products that contain PET demonstrated no ocular irritation or dermal sensitization. (Admittedly, lots of the TikTok hacks create truly incredible looks, with the ideas being totally game-changing.). So while it appears to be similar to eyeliner, it definitely isn't the same and shouldn't be used interchangeably without taking the proper steps to ensure that you're using them safely. I avoided the obvious ones like ColourPop but didnt realise this applied to the PMG palettes and wouldnt have wasted my money if I knew. COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer not for use around the eyes. It looks like Colourpop is using red lakes that are not FDA approved for use around the eyes. a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. Suitable for every skin tone, our ColourPop eyeshadow review found that this pigmented eyeshadow palette offers a range of color combinations to create that perfect eye look you have always wanted. We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. It takes a while to permanently rehydrate your eyes before a LASIK surgery but its well worth the effort cause I dont miss the dryness and constant irritation from wearing lenses all the time. They treat a lot of military, law enforcement etc. Also regarding Lasik. As a contact lens user and having super sensitive eyes, glitter has always been an issue for me. Many cosmetics companies rely on consumer ignorance about potential hazards. On the other hand, the soft blurring pigment technology provides a flawless complexion that lasts throughout the day. Im glad your eye was okay !! I have drier eyes, though I dont feel they are dry routinely, but Ive been told that Im unlikely to be a candidate for Lasik due to having some dryness currently. Your eyes must be exhausted! Light, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. If you wear eye makeup, it makes sense to take care in the types of products used, ensure that theyre adhering well to the area, and take care removing it all. retailers. in the U.S. is obviously absurd and negligent. We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! Because the tip of this felt tip liquid eyeliner pen is solid and not made of bristles, it has a higher payoff as the pigment appears darker on your skin after just one easy swipe. Approved for use: Eyes Lips, Face (but please use caution around the eyes). We earn commission on sales tracked from our links. It's better to use a creamy shadow eyeliner near your natural lip skin tone or to match your lipstick shade. Thank you! Cruelty Free Create clean lines and prevent feathering disasters with ColourPop's long-wearing and super pigmented Lippie Pencil liner, designed to be worn under your fave matching lip color. In fact, the ingredients in lip liner can make it dangerous to use as eyeliner, especially if you don't take the proper precautions to disinfect it with an alcohol-based cleanser, per Allure . She passed on the following info re colourpop eyeshadow. Not only for safety, but for environmental reasons. Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. no glitter is eye safe. Id rather it have one of the other 2 types of glitter mentioned in your article instead, though. I have seen an indie brand say 008 Polyester Glitter as one of their ingredients. Since this post was really focused on potential for eye irritation/injury, I focused on eye products (as those are also where the warnings apply, if they exist), but I know I will be exercising more caution in the removal process if I was wearing a very glittery highlighter/blush color! In particular we recommend them for nail polish, shimmer body lotion and soap. I just ordered blue contacts after 20 years of not playing with them and it was some youtubers suggestion (with code) I got them in, but they felt like they were too convaved and stood out too much on the inside of my eyelid. Is polyester glitter safer than PET glitter? Very Light, Pink, slight pink undertones. You would think that it would be easy to ascertain if glitter was safe or if this ingredient was safe for this area or not, but alas, it is not so simple. Also, Urban Decay Moondust shadows are in the same category of risk when worn on the eye as say MAC glitter? Light, Pink, moderately pink undertones. Gel . So, I didnt want people to take what happened to me and run with it in an alarmist way either so I tried to present ALL the information possible so that it can be more about readers armed with whatever info is available and making the decision based on their personal comfort level. I plan on buying many more things from Colourpop. Thank you once again Christine. Thank you so very much for investigating the PET conundrum, Christine. Even so, it may not be a good idea to have these larger particle sized powders near the eyes. Lip Plumpers. Sadly, glitter and I just dont work. However, you need to pair ColourPop BFF Eyeliner with BFF mascara if you want to complete your look. That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. , metallic baby blue with blue and silver pinpoints, Our famous Super Shock formula in metallic icy white! I have had friends who werent as affected as I was with dry eyes, so its worth looking into some more of you still are considering the procedure. Furthermore, this concealer contains plankton extract, a versatile skincare ingredient that protects your skin from blue light and UV radiation, helps prevent toxins and pollutants from penetrating your skin, and reduces oxidative stress. Lips. Im thinking that learning about all this is a good way for me to clean out my collection some more. Privacy Policy. Combination skin. Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. But hey, as it can happen to anyone, this stuff just shouldnt be manufactured. I dont know if it would make much difference to dry eyes (doubtfully), but worth looking into. Ad Choices. The entire collection. Eyeshadow. Seemingly, we appear to be extremely reliant on trusting brands to use ingredients that are safe in our cosmetics. "Colors intended for use around the eye have to be specially approved by the FDA.". In part of its findings, CIR wrote that a lack of case reports and no ongoing FDA regulatory actions suggested to the Panel that ocular injury is not likely. If, in fact, consumers sustain ocular injury from the use of PET glitter, then it seems it will fall to consumers to report those injuries to the FDA. The cream eyeshadow will work perfectly on the inner corner or even along the lashline. After some months (I dont remember exactly how long it was) I started finding it occasionally in other products. Eye Makeup Remover. . I love the bronzer and very much enjoy the Posh lipstick and lip liner. The Dupe List is here to help. The duo started ColourPop as an eCommerce business with only 31 shades of eyeshadow to see if people would like them, and they loved their products. Our ColourPop bronzer review investigated this product and discovered that it sculpts your features, lifts your cheekbones, and instantly leaves you with a warm, just-stepped-off-the-beach radiance. Only a sensation of grittiness if any fallout gets in my eye when I use that shade or the similarly textured Gilty Pleasure. The Panel concluded that modified terephthalate polymers were safe as cosmetic ingredients in the practices of use and concentration described in this safety assessment. (Safety Assessment of Modified Terephthalate Polymers as Used in Cosmetics, April 12, 2013), Within the report, CIR stated, In several use tests of eye shadows, gels, liners, and mascara containing PET (up to 46.272%), there were few reports of adverse effects, including in subjects wearing contact lenses (Table 5). Referring to Table 5 says that there is a very slight ocular irritant potential with the eyeshadow used that is normal for this type of product.. . Im glad youre OK. In the only instance where I had a problem (a year ago I received someone else's order instead of my own), Colorpop was quick to ship me my items when I informed them of their error, and they let me keep the items that I received in error. According to the ingredient list the colorants are, Red Lake 28 and Red Lake 7 both of which are on the FDAs list of colors that can be used in drugs and cosmetics. Very Light, Olive, cool undertones. Ive got enough issues still getting eyelid breakouts even avoiding the problematic pigment color. I think they wrote the 008 as the particle size. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. To me, that would imply that an eyeshadow palette being used as an eyeshadow palette should be safe. ColourPop Oh Snap is a slightly warm-toned, dark beige with a matte finish. Our ColourPop BFF eyeliner review team found that it is also easier for beginners to control, particularly if they want a sharp and defined cat-eye look because the flexible tip can glide on seamlessly with intense pigmentation without tugging or skipping. Love the brand, all the skincare products are tested and are very gentle on skin. I also found it lurking in some eyeshadow crayons. Quality of eyeshadows is just as good as products that are twice the price. My BFF is an makeup freak, biochemist, and an ophthalmologist MD. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. shop the collection, Get more time to pay with Klarna! And makeup *should* be care-free and fun. I do think though that I want to avoid borosilicate in my eye products. More safety and environmental regulations have been removed in the U.S. over the past couple of years. Im not sure if anyone is still posting to this thread but it seems that synthetic fluorphlogopite is used in many eyeshadows Ive looked up, including my much-loved Sydney Grace. But if you insist on trying this lip liner TikTok hack, be sure to sanitize it with a cleanser that has alcohol in it and, if it is a pencil, try using a sharpener to clear the pencil of any contaminants before using it on your eyes. 4,844 likes, 156 comments - Rose Siard (@roseandben) on Instagram: "I did a #bridalmakeup look today on my story!! And its hydrating and antioxidant properties are designed to keep your skin soft and glowing such that people might think you have just woken up. I guess I've been living under a rock because I'm 43 and just discovered them. The eyeliner has a cartridge of 0.55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. A high percentage of people who use the products from this company are blown away with their results. Want amazing offers and news on the latest consumer brands? is a light-medium, reddish-plum with warmer undertones and a matte finish. LOL! Its amazing how you can harness one negative experience and turn it into a systematic discussion about policy and regulation in the cosmetics Industry! What are the dangers of using this product around the eyes? The more uniform edge, as opposed to natural mica, seems to be why brands feel comfortable using larger particle-sized synthetic mica than natural mica. Its inexpensive but very high quality which means I can and do buy everything I want! liners And I guess colourpop for good alternatives for most of these things in fun colors. I have been using the colourpop foundation gor several years. Excellent article Christine, thank you for all your hard work and the hours you invested!! I wasnt able to find any pending petitions regarding glitter, and you can also view final rules regarding color additives (generally) here. I have always gone for the expensive high end makeups but after Covid Ive been having to save where I can. being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! It is important to note that not approved doesnt necessarily mean not safe but it doesnt mean that it is safe either. Im so glad you didnt have permanent damage from this experience. Eyeshadow palette should be filled with eyeshadows. Thank you very much for your well researched piece, Christine. Additionally, ColourPop BFF Eyeliner contains Caprylyl Glycol, an ingredient that works as a preservative and prevents bacteria from growing to spoil the formula. Some color additives, when used in combination, may form new pigments, which may not be approved for the intended use. ColourPop BFF Eyeliner is available in various colors such as white, canary yellow, true black, deep sapphire, dark brown, and bright bubblegum pink. Lightest, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. They include interesting verbiage under Details, copied and pasted below: In the USA, natural mica used in cosmetics is not allowed if larger than 150 microns in size. Are you having doubts about purchasing ColourPop? "The pigments are not interchangeable. 2. Thanks for this! Im always excited to find someone who is from Calgary, Alberta (or who has even heard of it). My understanding is it is (or was) a better method to avoid issues with things like night driving, especially as they are able to work on a larger surface with this method; ergo more tissue is available for treatment. Fully agree with this 100%. Clearly I dont deliberately eat glitter, but its inevitable that a small amount gets swallowed over the course of talking and drinking and I actually do wear glitter lips semi-regularly. Your California Privacy Rights. Also, high amounts of ingredients like fats, alcohol and waxes in lip liner, aren't exactly safe to use on eyes, per StyleCheer. No, your eyes probably won't fall out but the chances of giving yourself a sty or other serious reaction dramatically increase (there's a reason we don't keep mascara for years, and those are formulated for eyes). Dry skin. Fortunately, I walked away with minimal damage (antibiotics for a week and skip contacts for a few days), so I consider myself lucky and definitely think getting to the doctor sooner (about two hours) was the right move! In 2012, the FDA had replied to another media outlet with this: However, we are exercising enforcement discretion for a period of time. Comments that do not adhere to our is a light-medium, reddish-plum with warmer undertones and a matte finish. Would you please be able to weigh in with your thoughts always love your insight and analysis of these topics! Craft glitter is an entirely different thing and absolutely should never be anywhere near the eye. Moondust doesnt include plastic glitter from what I recall, but you can always check the ingredient list UD is pretty good about posting theirs! Our ColourPop review found that the company offers international shipping, but orders are subject to duty fees and customs as defined by your country. In addition to refreshing your tired-looking eyes, No Filter ColourPop Concealer masks large pores, age spots, camouflage dark circles, and other blemishes visible on your skin with just one swipe. Normal-to-Dry skin. Exploring synthetic fluorphlogopite options on TKB Trading, Cherika Moon also has a certificate of analysis that can be read (here), which listed particle size as 100 to 260 m. removed. I have worn glitter products for years, too, on the lid as well as below the lash line (not the waterline) not always fully aware of the risks but quite aware of potential risks in the last few years. FDA has not approved the use of glitter or polyethylene terephthalate as a color additive in cosmetics or any other FDA-regulated product. , An emerald green to gold to tealmulti chrome finish, A vibrant cobalt blue to purple duo chrome finish , A deep blue to teal to purplemulti chrome finish, An opalescent gold to pink to copper multi chrome finish, A vibrant pink to peach to goldmulti chrome finish , A metallic sage to terracotta duo chrome finish , A bright magenta to rich purple to bronzemulti chrome finish. These are still non-permitted color additives in eye-area use cosmetics. But yes, every time I go back in the winter, my poor already dry eyes are so dry. Nothing quite like having an up close and personal run-in with PET glitter to cause one to look deeper into its potential hazards! They have a few authorized sellers, which can be found on colourpop.com. You must pay all fees, duties, and other taxes that may be required when importing products from the United States. I live in the San Francisco/San Jose area now, but hardly anyone knows where Im from even though I think Calgary isnt that small anymore.